Third DCA · 3D25-1198 · Jun 21, 2026
Garcia v. Harbor Mutual Insurance Co.
By FloridaScore editorialOpinion dated Jun 21, 20261 min read
Related authority
Statute construed
Statute construed
The argument · FloridaScore analysis
What You Need to Know
The panel reviews a fee award after a rejected proposal for settlement and discusses the evidence needed to show a proposal was not made in good faith.
Analysis is FloridaScore's own work. It is never the court's language, and the official opinion controls.
The holding
A low proposal can be valid when the record supports a reasonable basis for the offer at the time it was served.
Summary
The panel reviews a fee award after a rejected proposal for settlement and discusses the evidence needed to show a proposal was not made in good faith.
Related topics
Disposition
AFFIRMED
As written by the court
“Affirmed”
The court affirmed without qualification.
How we classify →Opinion metadata
- Court
- Third District Court of Appeal
- Docket
- 3D25-1198
- Opinion date
- Jun 21, 2026
- Disposition
- Affirmed
- Judge / author
- Logue, J.
- Precedential status
- Published
- Case style
- Garcia v. Harbor Mutual Insurance Co.
FloridaScore is an independent publication and is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or acting on behalf of any court or government agency. The official opinion controls; always read it before relying on any summary. FloridaScore content is legal information, not legal advice, and does not create an attorney-client relationship.
Opinion dated Jun 21, 2026. Verify against the official opinion, docket, and any related statute or rule before relying on this analysis.